Let’s Talk

Website redesign vs new build

Redesign when the foundation is sound and the problem is how it looks or reads: the platform is fast, you own it, and it can do what you need. Rebuild when the foundation is the problem: slow, insecure, locked to a platform you’ve outgrown, or so patched that every change breaks something.

Not sure which fits? Tell me where you are and I’ll say honestly.

Send your current site, or a line about the business. I’ll reply with what I’d do in your position, even if it isn’t hiring me.

No newsletter. Just what you asked for, from me. Privacy

Side by side

RedesignNew build
What changesLook, layout, contentEverything, including the code and often the platform
KeepsURLs, platform, most functionalityOnly what you choose to bring across
SEO riskLower if URLs stayManageable with a redirect plan
Fixes speed problemsPartlyYes, if built well
Fixes lock-inNoYes, if you move to code you own
TimelineUsually shorterUsually longer

Which one suits you

Choose Redesign if…

  • the site is fast and secure, it just looks dated
  • your rankings are strong and you want minimal risk
  • the platform still does everything you need

Choose New build if…

  • the site is slow on phones and plugins keep piling up
  • you can’t move it, export it or change it the way you need
  • you’re repositioning the business, not just refreshing it

Test the foundation first

Run the site through PageSpeed Insights on mobile, check how many plugins or apps it depends on, and ask who can actually edit the code. If the answers are “slow”, “lots” and “nobody really”, a redesign puts new paint on a weak structure. If the scores are decent and the setup is clean, a redesign is the efficient move.

Protecting your search traffic

Either path can be done without losing rankings. The rule is the same: keep content that ranks, map every old URL to its new address, and set up 301 redirects before launch. I’ve written about whether a redesign will hurt your SEO in more detail.

FAQ

Redesign vs New build, answered

  1. Usually, but not always. A redesign on a fragile platform can turn into weeks of working around old code, and at that point a clean build can be the cheaper path.

  2. There’s no fixed schedule. Redesign when the site no longer reflects the business, underperforms, or is hard to maintain. Many sites can be refined continuously instead of replaced every few years.

  3. Yes. Content usually moves across, though it’s worth editing as you go. Old copy written for an old structure rarely fits a better one without changes.

Keep reading

Other comparisons

Next steps

Let’s begin

Let’s build something you’re proud to share.

Let’s Talk