Does Squarespace charge transaction fees?

Depending on the plan, Squarespace may add its own transaction fee on top of payment processing. Check the current plan details, since they change.

Can Shopify look as good as Squarespace?

Yes, with a good theme and good photography. Out of the box, Squarespace templates tend to look more polished; Shopify needs more care on the pages that aren’t products.

Is Shopify or Squarespace better for SEO?

Shopify gives you more SEO control. Shopify: Solid for product SEO; URL structure is fixed. Squarespace: Good defaults and editable titles, descriptions and redirects; less advanced control.

Do I own my website on Shopify or Squarespace?

Shopify (partial): Products, customers and orders as CSV; the theme has to be rebuilt elsewhere. Squarespace (partial): Some pages, galleries and one blog export in WordPress format, and products export separately as CSV. Layouts, styling and code don’t.

Shopify vs Squarespace

If the store is the business and you expect to grow, Shopify is the better foundation. If you’re a creative or service business selling a modest catalogue alongside everything else, Squarespace’s commerce is often enough, and its templates make the rest of the site look better with less effort. The tipping point is usually catalogue size and order volume.

Not sure which fits? Send me your site and I’ll give you my honest view.

Whether it’s Shopify, Squarespace or something else, I’ll give you a straight recommendation for your business. Free.

Side by side

Ratings are my own assessment for a typical small business, as of October 2026. Platforms change their features and plans often, so check the vendor’s current documentation before you decide.

Shopify vs Squarespace comparison
	Shopify	Squarespace
What it is	The hosted commerce platform most small and mid-size stores should start with.	Polished templates and a tidy editor, for brands that want to look good fast.
Ownership and portability	PartialProducts, customers and orders export; the theme only runs on Shopify.	PartialSome pages, galleries and one blog export in WordPress format, products as CSV; the design and code stay.
SEO control	StrongSolid for product SEO; URL structure is fixed.	AdequateGood defaults and editable titles, descriptions and redirects; less advanced control.
AI-search readiness	GoodProduct schema in most themes; content pages are simpler.	MixedAdds basic structured data automatically; custom schema needs code injection on plans that allow it.
Performance	GoodA fast platform; heavy app use is the usual cause of slow stores.	VariesFine on lean pages; heavy galleries can slow it down.
Design freedom	FlexibleThemes plus Liquid; headless for full freedom.	FlexibleFlexible within the template system, with freer section layouts and custom CSS.
E-commerce	SpecialistThe reason to choose it.	GoodCapable for small shops and digital products.
Maintenance burden	LightPlatform managed; app and theme updates need watching.	MinimalFully managed.
Learning curve	GentleStraightforward admin; good stores take skill.	EasyEasy to pick up.
Pricing model	Monthly plan plus payment processing fees; most stores add paid apps on top.	Monthly or yearly subscription tiers; commerce features and transaction fees vary by plan.
Day-to-day editing	The Shopify admin and theme editor.	The Squarespace editor with drag-and-drop sections.

Which one suits you

Choose Shopify if…

online sales are the main job of the site
you need advanced inventory, shipping rules or multi-channel selling
you want access to a large ecosystem of commerce apps

Choose Squarespace if…

you sell a few products or digital downloads next to a portfolio or services
design polish matters more than commerce depth
you want one subscription with scheduling and email built in

The difference that matters most

Shopify is a store that can have a website; Squarespace is a website that can have a store. That sounds glib, but it shows up everywhere: in my view Shopify’s checkout, order management and app market go deeper, while Squarespace’s content pages and templates are more refined.

A Calgary ceramicist selling twenty pieces a season alongside her portfolio and workshop bookings fits Squarespace well. A Kelowna supplement brand with subscriptions, wholesale pricing and hundreds of SKUs needs Shopify. Shopify’s content pages are basic, so a content-heavy brand there should plan its information architecture carefully.

Where each one leads

Counted from my ratings in the table above.

Shopify leads on seo control, ai-search readiness, performance and e-commerce.

Squarespace leads on maintenance burden and learning curve.

Best fit for Shopify: any business where online sales are the main job of the site. Best fit for Squarespace: creatives, studios and small brands that want a good-looking site quickly.

Switching between them

Moving from Squarespace to Shopify, the catalogue comes over by CSV or Shopify’s import tools, but layouts and styling are rebuilt in a Shopify theme, and pages and blog posts are imported or recreated. Shopify’s fixed /products/ and /collections/ URLs mean nearly every old address changes, so add 301 redirects in Shopify’s admin for all of them. Shopify to Squarespace works the same way in reverse.

FAQ